Columns, Essays, & Analysis

Analysis, commentary, essays, and criticism on the most consequential legal questions of the moment.

Politico Jan 4, 2026

Trump May Have Accidentally Pardoned the Jan. 6 Pipe Bomber

The Justice Department has touted the arrest, but he might still walk free.

Politico Dec 19, 2025

5 Rules for Reading the Epstein Files

How to review a mountain of potentially explosive documents like a pro.

Politico Dec 11, 2025

Remember the Torture Memos? The Boat Strike Memos May Be Worse.

The Trump administration needs to release the legal analysis underpinning its controversial military campaign.

Politico Nov 5, 2025

‘The Courts Might as Well Just Shut Down’

As the Supreme Court takes up Trump’s tariffs, two conservative legal scholars fight it out on the issue.

Politico Nov 1, 2025

‘At What Point Does This Cross a Line Into International Criminality?’

An expert on international law weighs in on the legality and global implications of the Trump administration’s drug boat killings.

Politico Sep 4, 2025

Trump Is Trying to Blackmail the Supreme Court

The legal arguments for Trump’s tariffs are weak, so he’s arguing their rejection would bring ruin.

Politico Aug 25, 2025

‘We Still Don’t Know How Far They’ll Go’

Foreign diplomats are growing nervous about the rule of law in Trump’s America — and it could complicate law enforcement across the globe.

Politico Mar 28, 2025

Why Major Law Firms Surrendered to Trump

A reality check about the industry.

Politico Dec 21, 2024

ABC Had Good Legal Reasons to Settle with Trump

It doesn’t mean the press is caving to Trump.

Politico Nov 7, 2024

Trump Got Away With It — Because of the Biden Administration's Massive Missteps

How Merrick Garland and the Biden team failed to hold Trump accountable.

Politico Sep 30, 2024

The Coming Trump Revenge Tour

Trump has campaigned on a wave of retaliatory criminal prosecutions. It's not the first time he's promised to lock up his rivals — but a second term would be different.

Politico Jul 2, 2024

The Supreme Court Gave Trump a Stunning Gift — and Rewrote the Constitution

The decision may go down as one of the most brazenly political decisions in the history of the Supreme Court.

Politico Apr 23, 2024

Inside the Off-the-Record Calls Held by Anti-Trump Legal Pundits

Every week, a group of high-profile lawyers and former officials meet on Zoom to discuss the legal cases against Donald Trump. We got a peek inside.

New York Magazine Aug 2, 2023

The Most Important Criminal Prosecution in American History

The Justice Department's case against Trump is necessary and just.

Slate Jun 5, 2023

How Bad Is James Comey's New Crime Novel, Really?

The evident sincerity and undeniable mediocrity of the effort are its most endearing qualities.

The New York Times Nov 17, 2022

Trump Faces Five Major Investigations. He Has Dozens of Ways Out.

An interactive visual exploration of the many paths available to a former president facing unprecedented legal jeopardy.

Columbia Journalism Review Aug 6, 2021

Don’t Treat Trump’s Legal Woes Like the Mueller Report

The public deserves our best effort to convey and evaluate the full range of possibilities as facts continue to unfold, and to acknowledge the many uncertainties that remain.

The New York Review of Books Jul 15, 2021

Merrick Garland’s Moderation to Excess

As attorney general, he is the United States’ top law enforcement officer. But is he enforcing enough?

The New York Review of Books Jan 6, 2021

Wanted: Lead Suspect in Election Fraud Conspiracy

Identifies Donald Trump as the central figure in a campaign to subvert the 2020 election.

The New York Review of Books Nov 20, 2020

The Case for Prosecuting Trump

An examination of the legal and political implications of pursuing criminal charges against a former president.

The New York Review of Books Sep 25, 2020

When the Rule of Law Turns into Rule By Law

This selective use of the law is dangerous precisely because it has a veneer of legal legitimacy that covers a corruption deeply corrosive to the political order.